Moral autonomy, selfdetermination and animal rights. With the end of the cold war, ethnic conflict appears to be reemerging as subnational groups fight to be heard and represented. Candidate university of oregon kathleen stricklandcohen, ph. The law and economics of indian self rule joseph p. The accommodation of conflicting rights procedural aspects of international law hannum, hurst on. African studies american studies ancient near east and egypt art history asian studies book history and cartography biblical studies classical studies education. Autonomy, sovereignty, and selfdetermination hurst hannum.
Intervention and collective selfdetermination jeff mcmahan. Redefining autonomy, selfdetermination and sovereignty as. Selfdetermination theory sdt is a broad theory of human personality and motivation concerned with how the individual interacts with and depends on the social environment. This thesis examines self determination as a human right, focusing on the central question whether international law allows for a right of external self determination in the form of unilateral secession when the internal right of self determination is breached. Selfdetermination is the right of a nation or people, which have a separate and distinct identity. Defining the right to selfgovernment when cracking open a thesaurus to find synonyms for freedom, one will undoubtedly come across the words autonomy and sovereignty. Sovereignty, territorial integrity, and the right to. Jun 02, 2016 distinct from sovereignty, self determination in this local context reflected ideas of collective participation, cultural distinctiveness, self governance, free choice and freedom from discrimination. This research finds that recognition of, or references to, the right to selfdetermination of peoples are absent from eu law sources.
If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise cambridge core to connect with your account. European union to try to execute state shattering selfdetermination with the intent and expectation to be immediately accepted as a new individual member of the european union. Autonomy, competence, and relatedness in the classroom applying selfdetermination theory to educational practice christopher p. University of pennsylvania press, 1996 law 534 pages. State sovereignty selfdetermination, selfgovernance. Self determination the notion of collective self determination is as elusive as the notion of intervention and is variously understood in the literature.
For sovereignty is limited not only by the right of other states and the innumerable political and economic ties that bind them. Through an analysis of contemporary international legal norms and an examination of several specific case studiesincluding hong kong, india, the transnational problems of the kurds and saamis, nicaragua, northern ireland, spain, sri lanka, and. Kosovo, which was previously an autonomous unit of serbia declared. Issues like these were discussed in slaughter, annemarie, a liberal theory of international law 2000 94 american society of international law proceedings 240. Selfdetermination can be defined as a the act or power of making ones own decisions and determining ones own political status. Respeta i taotao tano the recognition and establishment. Selfdetermination, occupation and the authority to. Hurst hannum autonomy, sovereignty and selfdetermination who maintains that neither sovereignty nor selfdetermination is an absolute right. The project on state, sovereignty, and selfdetermination addresses issues of boundaries, identity, variants of autonomy, governance, selfdetermination, selfdeterminations potential devolutive and stateshattering capabilities, and the emerging version of selfdetermination as defining ones own destiny. The principle of selfdetermination imposes a negative duty on states to refrain from interference in one anothers affairs. State, sovereignty, and selfdetermination liechtenstein. Conceptualising selfdetermination and secession selfdetermination is a notion of political rights that can be traced back to ancient greece and rome. These concepts provide moral legitimacy to the struggles in the region, even to those that often become violent.
This is done through a series of case studies ranging from the kurds to the south tyroleans of italy. The international community has sought to resolve this tension by effectively eliminating the circumstances in which the right to self determination equates with a right. The right of a people to selfdetermination is a cardinal principle in modern international law. Demands for autonomy or minority rights have given rise to conflicts, often violent, in every region of the world and under every political system. Many of eastern asias current disputes to sovereignty and selfdetermination stem from unresolved. Autonomy, competence, and relatedness in the classroom applying self determination theory to educational practice christopher p. The meaning of international law father robert araujo abstract this essay contends that popular sovereignty and the other rights enumerated in the uni. While a sovereignty exercising state can be a totalitarian regime, it can also be a democratic one in which. Autonomy, sovereignty, and selfdetermination hurst hannum published by university of pennsylvania press hannum, hurst. Not finding a compromise only prolongs the misery and suffering of all, especially. Redefining autonomy, selfdetermination and sovereignty as a tool of peace many nationalist struggles and ethnic conflicts in northeast india have been rooted in the assertion of the idea of autonomy, selfdetermination and sovereignty. Self determination exists in tension with the principles of sovereignty and territorial integrity that form the foundation of the international system of states.
This thesis examines selfdetermination as a human right, focusing on the central question whether international law allows for a right of external selfdetermination in the form of unilateral secession when the internal right of selfdetermination is breached. Aboriginal selfgovernment in nunavut alternatives north. In most cases, the minority group is a minority which has felt disadvantaged and discriminated against. The right to selfdetermination has recently reemerged as the focus of much debate, as its fulfillmentor denialquite often results in mass violence. Focusing on individuals and groups rather than states, the author searches for means of accommodating conflicting claims.
A critical point in the course of indian selfrule the last three decades have witnessed a remarkable resurgence of. In this section i track the history of colonisation in australian and indigenous affairs policy as it relates to the right to selfdetermination. Through an analysis of contemporary international legal norms and. Party competition over selfdetermination in south tyrol matthias scantamburlo and gunther pallaver, university of innsbruck matthias.
If you feel the need, go ahead and check your thesaurus now. Can autonomy fulfil the right to selfdetermination. Demands for autonomy or minority rights have given rise to conflicts, often violent, in every region of. There is no objective concept that is universally applicable and yet it is of foundational importance to. The right to selfdetermination is a fundamental tenet of international law, influencing relationships between states and amongst the subunits. The focus of the european project, in direct contrast to the glorification of nationhood, is on consensual decisionmaking rather than sovereignty, making selfdetermination obsolete in a reality of eu integration.
Document resume ed 407 321 so 027 204 harris, will. The internal aspect of selfdetermination is autonomy which widely guarantees the right to participate in democracy henriksen, 2008. Fordham international law journal volume 24, issue 5 2000 article 1 sovereignty, human rights, and. Reducing the right of self determination to a right to autonomy is not in accordance with the idea of self determination as a human right and neither is the denial of the right of secession in absoluto. Selfdetermination, occupation and the authority to exploit. Your use of the jstor archive indicates your acceptance of the terms. While this book is written from the perspective of an international lawyer, its focus is on individuals and groups rather than states, the traditional subjects and objects of international law. Sovereignty in the exercise of the right to selfdetermination constitutes an impressively solid piece of research. Nosd government, and it is for this reason that outsiders are obliged not to interfere. Representations of a relationship dan sarooshi abstract the meaning of the concept of sovereignty is largely contingent upon the text in which it figures. Human rights, autonomy and national sovereignty michael dusche university of tubingen this paper1 examines the legal and ethical problems involved in reconciling two separate rights, each of which plays a fundamental role in the current philosophical debate surrounding international relations and international law.
On this view, the right of collective self determination is the right to. Nunavuts selfdetermination is a contemporary example that aboriginal and canadian sovereignty do not have to be. The statist conception equates selfdetermination with the familiar idea of state autonomy. Self determination theory sdt is a broad theory of human personality and motivation concerned with how the individual interacts with and depends on the social environment. By using this service, you agree that you will only keep articles for personal use, and will not. Reimagining sovereignty in international investment law volume 65 issue 4 edward guntrip. Project muse autonomy, sovereignty, and selfdetermination. Archived from the original pdf on january 20, 2012. It is argued that there is a right of unilateral secession. Historically, canadian sovereignty depends on maintaining the relationship between canadas indigenous people and the crown through treaties of peace and friendship macklem 2001, 122. The internal aspect of self determination is autonomy which widely guarantees the right to participate in democracy henriksen, 2008. A negotiated sovereigntyautonomy approach seems to meet both criteria. Department of state s policy planning staff selfdetermination sovereignty, territorial integrity, and the right to secession patricia carley united states institute of peace.
Apart from a comprehensive and observant assessment of the entire discourse as to date including international practice, it adds a number of insights and nuances, in particular a dose of realism by taking into account international relations, that make it an original. Food sovereignty an intensely debated concept loosely described means that people are able to exercise autonomy over their food systems while concurrently ensuring that the productiondistribution of food is carried out in socially just, culturally safe, and ecologically sustainable ways. European union integration and national selfdetermination. Redefining autonomy, selfdetermination and sovereignty as a. Reducing the right of selfdetermination to a right to autonomy is not in accordance with the idea of selfdetermination as a human right and neither is the denial of the right of secession in absoluto. Sovereignty in the exercise of the right to selfdetermination. Such conflicts are aggravated by the uncertain position of the international community, which cannot rely on precise guidelines for assessing the right to selfdetermination. A critical point in the course of indian self rule the last three decades have witnessed a remarkable resurgence of the indian nations in the united states.
Distinct from sovereignty, selfdetermination in this local context reflected ideas of collective participation, cultural distinctiveness, selfgovernance, free choice and freedom from discrimination. Sovereignty in the exercise of the right to selfdetermination detangles the relationship between a number of principles of international law and the exercise of sovereign power. Selfdetermination, land reform, and international law reginald l. I deny selfdetermination entails an unconditional right to a sovereign state. Ebook social sciences law international law hurst hannum. Demands for autonomy or minority rights have given rise to conflicts. Define and discuss with students the ideas of sovereignty and selfdetermination. Author harris, will title autonomy and sovereignty as the impossible elements of a. In this section i track the history of colonisation in australian and indigenous affairs policy as it relates to the right to self determination. Nonetheless, it was during the french revolution that self determination was declared to be a right of nations to statehood and sovereignty. In an exclusive setting, highlevel independent academic experts and practitioners from europe, the united states, and asia discussed the concept of autonomy, as opposed to fullfledged independence, as a.
Autonomy, relatedness, competence 1 minute read by erin folletto casali as much as people like talking about maslows pyramid, we already know theres little theoretical basis for it. Selfdetermination of indigenous peoples within the human. The right to selfdetermination and international law nzlii. Department of state s policy planning staff selfdetermination sovereignty, territorial integrity, and the right to secession. The word free is more complicated, but it too has an ambiguity similar to that of autonomous and independent, especially when applied to nations and states. In each of the nine situations, autonomy, selfgovernment, or selfdetermination is demanded by a group within an existing state, in order to protect the groups culture.
Streater abstract zimbabwelike most african postcolonial nation stateshas been criticized and castigated for exercising its legal rights to selfdetermination, autonomy and sovereignty over land and resourcesespecially when these conflict with the. Quoting tabajdi exterior selfdetermination is the right to separate, that came up against state sovereignty. Hurst hannum autonomy, sovereignty, and selfdetermination. Sovereignty, selfdetermination, and human rights from. Autonomy, sovereignty, and selfdetermination pdf hurst hannum autonomy, sovereignty, and selfdetermination the accommodation of conflicting rights. Sovereignty, territorial integrity and right of self.
1056 416 472 1437 731 52 1159 414 123 25 1570 1332 1233 417 1069 1323 1135 713 1475 207 776 1368 875 1072 631 256 561 704 1404 151 467 1390 491 570 1397 172 816 37 268 746 692 1092 1129 1099 631 670